• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

site logo
The Electronic Journal for English as a Second Language
search
  • Home
  • About TESL-EJ
  • Vols. 1-15 (1994-2012)
    • Volume 1
      • Volume 1, Number 1
      • Volume 1, Number 2
      • Volume 1, Number 3
      • Volume 1, Number 4
    • Volume 2
      • Volume 2, Number 1 — March 1996
      • Volume 2, Number 2 — September 1996
      • Volume 2, Number 3 — January 1997
      • Volume 2, Number 4 — June 1997
    • Volume 3
      • Volume 3, Number 1 — November 1997
      • Volume 3, Number 2 — March 1998
      • Volume 3, Number 3 — September 1998
      • Volume 3, Number 4 — January 1999
    • Volume 4
      • Volume 4, Number 1 — July 1999
      • Volume 4, Number 2 — November 1999
      • Volume 4, Number 3 — May 2000
      • Volume 4, Number 4 — December 2000
    • Volume 5
      • Volume 5, Number 1 — April 2001
      • Volume 5, Number 2 — September 2001
      • Volume 5, Number 3 — December 2001
      • Volume 5, Number 4 — March 2002
    • Volume 6
      • Volume 6, Number 1 — June 2002
      • Volume 6, Number 2 — September 2002
      • Volume 6, Number 3 — December 2002
      • Volume 6, Number 4 — March 2003
    • Volume 7
      • Volume 7, Number 1 — June 2003
      • Volume 7, Number 2 — September 2003
      • Volume 7, Number 3 — December 2003
      • Volume 7, Number 4 — March 2004
    • Volume 8
      • Volume 8, Number 1 — June 2004
      • Volume 8, Number 2 — September 2004
      • Volume 8, Number 3 — December 2004
      • Volume 8, Number 4 — March 2005
    • Volume 9
      • Volume 9, Number 1 — June 2005
      • Volume 9, Number 2 — September 2005
      • Volume 9, Number 3 — December 2005
      • Volume 9, Number 4 — March 2006
    • Volume 10
      • Volume 10, Number 1 — June 2006
      • Volume 10, Number 2 — September 2006
      • Volume 10, Number 3 — December 2006
      • Volume 10, Number 4 — March 2007
    • Volume 11
      • Volume 11, Number 1 — June 2007
      • Volume 11, Number 2 — September 2007
      • Volume 11, Number 3 — December 2007
      • Volume 11, Number 4 — March 2008
    • Volume 12
      • Volume 12, Number 1 — June 2008
      • Volume 12, Number 2 — September 2008
      • Volume 12, Number 3 — December 2008
      • Volume 12, Number 4 — March 2009
    • Volume 13
      • Volume 13, Number 1 — June 2009
      • Volume 13, Number 2 — September 2009
      • Volume 13, Number 3 — December 2009
      • Volume 13, Number 4 — March 2010
    • Volume 14
      • Volume 14, Number 1 — June 2010
      • Volume 14, Number 2 – September 2010
      • Volume 14, Number 3 – December 2010
      • Volume 14, Number 4 – March 2011
    • Volume 15
      • Volume 15, Number 1 — June 2011
      • Volume 15, Number 2 — September 2011
      • Volume 15, Number 3 — December 2011
      • Volume 15, Number 4 — March 2012
  • Vols. 16-Current
    • Volume 16
      • Volume 16, Number 1 — June 2012
      • Volume 16, Number 2 — September 2012
      • Volume 16, Number 3 — December 2012
      • Volume 16, Number 4 – March 2013
    • Volume 17
      • Volume 17, Number 1 – May 2013
      • Volume 17, Number 2 – August 2013
      • Volume 17, Number 3 – November 2013
      • Volume 17, Number 4 – February 2014
    • Volume 18
      • Volume 18, Number 1 – May 2014
      • Volume 18, Number 2 – August 2014
      • Volume 18, Number 3 – November 2014
      • Volume 18, Number 4 – February 2015
    • Volume 19
      • Volume 19, Number 1 – May 2015
      • Volume 19, Number 2 – August 2015
      • Volume 19, Number 3 – November 2015
      • Volume 19, Number 4 – February 2016
    • Volume 20
      • Volume 20, Number 1 – May 2016
      • Volume 20, Number 2 – August 2016
      • Volume 20, Number 3 – November 2016
      • Volume 20, Number 4 – February 2017
    • Volume 21
      • Volume 21, Number 1 – May 2017
      • Volume 21, Number 2 – August 2017
      • Volume 21, Number 3 – November 2017
      • Volume 21, Number 4 – February 2018
    • Volume 22
      • Volume 22, Number 1 – May 2018
      • Volume 22, Number 2 – August 2018
      • Volume 22, Number 3 – November 2018
      • Volume 22, Number 4 – February 2019
    • Volume 23
      • Volume 23, Number 1 – May 2019
      • Volume 23, Number 2 – August 2019
      • Volume 23, Number 3 – November 2019
      • Volume 23, Number 4 – February 2020
    • Volume 24
      • Volume 24, Number 1 – May 2020
      • Volume 24, Number 2 – August 2020
      • Volume 24, Number 3 – November 2020
      • Volume 24, Number 4 – February 2021
    • Volume 25
      • Volume 25, Number 1 – May 2021
      • Volume 25, Number 2 – August 2021
      • Volume 25, Number 3 – November 2021
      • Volume 25, Number 4 – February 2022
    • Volume 26
      • Volume 26, Number 1 – May 2022
      • Volume 26, Number 2 – August 2022
      • Volume 26, Number 3 – November 2022
      • Volume 26, Number 4 – February 2023
    • Volume 27
      • Volume 27, Number 1 – May 2023
      • Volume 27, Number 2 – August 2023
      • Volume 27, Number 3 – November 2023
      • Volume 27, Number 4 – February 2024
    • Volume 28
      • Volume 28, Number 1 – May 2024
      • Volume 28, Number 2 – August 2024
      • Volume 28, Number 3 – November 2024
      • Volume 28, Number 4 – February 2025
    • Volume 29
      • Volume 29, Number 1 – May 2025
  • Books
  • How to Submit
    • Submission Info
    • Ethical Standards for Authors and Reviewers
    • TESL-EJ Style Sheet for Authors
    • TESL-EJ Tips for Authors
    • Book Review Policy
    • Media Review Policy
    • APA Style Guide
  • Editorial Board
  • Support

Talk about It! An Integrated Approach to Bold, Dynamic Topics

September 1998 — Volume 3, Number 3

Talk about It! An Integrated Approach to Bold, Dynamic Topics

Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press (1997)

Co-Author’s Comments:

Talk about It!: An Integrated Approach to Bold, Dynamic Topics was reviewed in the March, 1998 issue of TESL-EJ. As one might expect, there were both positive and negative comments in the review. However, several points about the book need clarifying to put the review into perspective.

The reviewer objected to the fact that Talk about It! is an integrated skills text but has the word “talk” in its title which apparently misled her into believing that the text was a speaking text. The subtitle of the book, An Integrated Approach to Bold, Dynamic Topics and a paragraph in the introduction of the book clearly state that Talk about It! focuses on integrated skills. The activities are designed to develop vocabulary, build learning strategies and give students the opportunity to practice language before being asked to use it. The prepare, plan, practice format is achieved through listening, speaking, reading and writing activities. Students make choices, negotiate meaning, and give feedback to one another as they work through the activities. We make no apologies for making it an integrated text or for the title. We believe that most teachers do more than run through each activity one by one; they talk about it and their students talk about it.

The reviewer asks whether the themes we cover in the text are “the sum total of young people’s interests?” Obviously they are not. We could not possibly cover the sum total of young people’s interests, nor did we try to. We chose topics and activities that have proved successful with our students.

As the reviewer points out, slang and idioms are a big part of the book. We include activities for learning slang and idioms because our students have asked for them. We agree with the reviewer that slang is often short-lived, which is why many of the activities centering on slang require students to gather slang from native speaker peers. They will learn from their peers what is current and what is passe. Again, we expect that teachers will use these activities as vehicles for discussion.

The main concern we have with the review is that, through absolutely no fault of her own, the reviewer reviewed only the Student Workbook of Talk about It! and not the complete text which is contained in the Teacher’s Manual. The reviewer walked the readers through a unit of the book and commented on each activity in the unit. As I followed along, I realized that she was missing activities. She had taken us through the Student Workbook not the Teacher’s Manual. The Student Workbook is just that, a workbook of readings and activities [-1-] for the student to write in. Pages are perforated so that exercises may be torn out to hand in to the teacher. The Teacher’s Manual contains the complete unit with pre-and post-activities designed to help prepare students for the workbook activities, practice language in the safe context of the classroom and then use that language in less structured situations. The Teacher’s Manual includes games, information searches, debriefing, discussion activities and pre- and post-reading activities. The “Live and Learn” section of each unit offers suggestions for extending the lesson beyond the borders of the classroom. Perhaps the reviewer’s impression of the book would have been different had she had the opportunity to actually use the Teacher’s Manual of Talk about It! as it was meant to be used, that is, as an integrated skills text, perhaps not. We regret that she didn’t get this opportunity.

Melinda Sayavedra, co-author
Oregon State University


Reviewer’s Response:

So do I. And I would suggest that the authors take the issue up with the promotion department at The University of Michigan Press. I am all the more sorry as I realise from what Melinda Sayavedra writes that the real book was the Teacher’s Manual. Nothing in the Student Workbook led me to suppose that there was anything else, in spite of looking because I felt the Workbook was unfinished and superficial. No wonder. This was like reviewing a film by reading the script only without seeing the film. I hate giving negative reviews or doing a bad job. I love to love books. I am sure the book deserved better treatment and only hope it can be reviewed more thoroughly in the near future.

Nicole Décuré
Université Paul Sabatier, Toulouse, France
<decure@cict.fr>

© Copyright rests with authors. Please cite TESL-EJ appropriately.

Editor’s Note: Dashed numbers in square brackets indicate the end of each page for purposes of citation.

[-2-]

© 1994–2025 TESL-EJ, ISSN 1072-4303
Copyright of articles rests with the authors.